Probably Stolen Butcher Guide
The Probably Stolen Butcher is a wanted criminal with a 450-credit bounty. He sells raw meat at a discount, returns every 7 days if you let him go, and comes back for revenge if you report him. Full timeline, rewards and the Sawyer hunting service.
The Butcher is a wanted criminal from the Lower Levels with a 450-credit bounty. He first comes to sell raw meat — buying his whole stock is reported to give a 25% wholesale discount — and you can report him while he is at the window. Reporting him does not make him disappear: expect revenge later, and budget for Sawyer's 500-credit hunting service to end it.
Source note
This page is compiled from public guides and player reports checked on 5 November 2026. It has not been independently played through in 1.0.0.6. Day numbers, stock lists and reward amounts come from those public sources; the game's current build always wins.
The public sources document the 1.0 release builds 26274380 (Rev1) and 26284217 (Rev3). 1.0.0.6 is Rev6 (31 October). Its patch notes only mention a mod-system security update and a Menu/Back key, so there is no evidence these Butcher values changed — but that is not the same as confirming them in Rev6.
Who the Butcher is
- A Lower Levels citizen in a red cap and bloody apron, carrying a satchel, a crowbar and meat. He sells meat and loot scavenged from the Abandoned Sections.
- He is on the Wanted poster. Do not identify him by the apron alone — always compare his face with the poster.
- He is not the Organ Trader starting scenario. The Organ Trader is a post-launch update pitched "for the Butcher fans"; do not treat it as content already in the game.
When he first appears
Reported day numbers differ, but the two accounts are not contradictory. One guide gives the earliest possible appearance: Day 14, or Day 5 if you skipped the intro. A separate playthrough log first met him on Day 19 as a seller, saw the Wanted listing on Day 20, and reported him on Day 26. One is a window, the other is a single run — treat the day as a range, not a fixed date.
The first-appearance window is community-reported and has not been re-checked in 1.0.0.6 for prologue and no-prologue starts.What he sells on the first visit
- Raw Meat (Small) ×2, Raw Meat (Standard) ×1, Animal Fat ×1, Crowbar ×1 and a Small Satchel ×1, with 25% off if you buy everything.
- Inside the Small Satchel: a Scavenger's Token, a journal entry, Peat, Common Electronic Parts and an Energy Drink. The journal is about a scavenger in the Abandoned Sections; no confirmed connection to Eleanor or Georgio has been found, so do not claim one.
Keep trading vs report him
| Choice | What happens (reported) |
|---|---|
| Let him go | He returns with more meat every 7 days from the first meeting. Later deliveries are flagged as stolen (Heat) and come with a 20% wholesale discount. |
| Report him at the window | You get the 450-credit bounty. Hold the teal Call Security button on the counter for about half a second — a single click does nothing. Correct reports also add Security reputation. |
| Buy everything, then report him | Reported as possible: buy the discounted stock first, then hold Call Security while he is still at the window. |
Revenge after arrest
- About 6 days after the arrest, you wake to "MEAT" written across your storefront in blood.
- Three days after the following morning, a meat cleaver and a threat note appear. The cleaver is a usable item — it can also butcher animals you own — and you do not need to hand it to anyone to progress.
- One day later, Sawyer can offer a 500-credit hunting service to take care of the Butcher. Sawyer is tied to the Janitorial Service and the Underground Exchange.
Open questions
Checked against public sources on 5 November 2026, not played through in 1.0.0.6:
- The exact first-appearance day, with and without the prologue;
- The first-visit stock list and the 25% discount;
- The 7-day return interval and the 20% discount on later stolen deliveries;
- The revenge timeline and the 500-credit hunting service fee;
- Whether the cleaver has any use beyond butchering and the threat-note scene.
The 450-credit bounty, the first-visit 25% discount, the later 20% discount, the 7-day return and the revenge timeline are consistent across multiple public guides. One playthrough log shows the credit balance rising by exactly 450 after the report. That makes them well-corroborated, not verified: none of those sources is Rev6, and the 1.0.0.6 patch notes do not mention the Butcher at all.
If the current build disagrees with this page, the build is right.
Read next
- Report him without ruining your reputation: Wanted Criminals & Reporting
- Who Sawyer is and what the crew trades: Underground Exchange Guide
- How arrests and evidence work: Endings, Security & Arrests
Frequently Asked Questions
Is reporting the Butcher worth 450 credits?
Yes for the bounty, but budget for the revenge chain and the 500-credit hunting service. The net cost can be higher than the bounty once you count that in.
Will he stop coming if I report him?
No. Arrest does not end this story; he returns in the revenge chain.
Should I buy his meat?
Only if you can sell or use raw meat. The first-visit discount is the best price reported.
Is the Butcher the Organ Trader?
No. The Organ Trader is a post-launch starting scenario pitched for Butcher fans; it is not the same as this NPC and should not be described as already live in 1.0.
Related guides
Probably Stolen Lou Guide
Lou in Probably Stolen: a 1,500-credit wanted criminal who plants a bomb, leaves a toy box, and demands 1,500 credits. When Lou first visits, what not to touch, and how the story continues after you report Lou.
Probably Stolen Characters: Eleanor, Lou, Serpico & the Butcher
A source-checked index of Probably Stolen's named characters: Eleanor's fully documented day-23 to day-29 route, Leroy the fake inspector, community-reported Lou and Butcher routes, and what is still unpublished for Cadet Serpico.
Probably Stolen Underground Exchange: Unlock Day, All 7 Trades & Weekly Pool
The Underground Exchange is Sawyer's overnight trade service. What unlocks it, the 7 permanent recipes, the weekly rotation and why a deposit can come back with nothing.
All guides for this game
- Probably Stolen Lou Guide
- Probably Stolen Underground Exchange: Unlock Day, All 7 Trades & Weekly Pool
- Probably Stolen Characters: Eleanor, Lou, Serpico & the Butcher
- Probably Stolen Evaporator Guide: Chemistry Steps & Reducing Agent
- Probably Stolen Liquid Luck & Luck: Georgio, Lottery & Scratchers
- Probably Stolen Radioactive Waste: How to Dispose of It Properly
- Probably Stolen Traditional Chinese & Mods: Setup & 1.0.0.6 Fixes
- Probably Stolen Trainer Explained: What 风灵月影 Means & the Risks
- Probably Stolen Vending Machine Guide: Overnight Sales & Upgrades
- Probably Stolen Wanted Criminals: How to Report Them Safely
- Probably Stolen All 21 Achievements Guide: We Have Rats, Clean Hands & Prodigious
- Probably Stolen Factions & Reputation Guide: Perks, Permits & Attracting Rich Buyers
- Probably Stolen Money Making Guide: Water, Wine & Liquid Luck
- Probably Stolen Endings, Security Arrest & Eleanor Quest Guide
- Probably Stolen Production Chains: Six Water Grades, Furnace & Wine Recipes
- Probably Stolen Save File Location
- Probably Stolen Starting Professions: All 9 Backgrounds Explained
- How to Identify Augs in Probably Stolen: 3 Official Tells & 6 Checks
- Probably Stolen Beginner Guide: Daily Loop, Rent & Opening Tips
- Probably Stolen Appraisal Guide: How to Spot Fake Cigarettes, Water & Rare Goods
- Probably Stolen Is Out: Price, Launch Numbers & Bundle Deals